Cutting speeds: Difference between revisions

From Wurst-Wasser.net
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(27 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 13: Line 13:


{| border="1" class="wikitable sortable"
{| border="1" class="wikitable sortable"
! cutter !! diameter (mm) !! speed (mm/min) !! attack (mm) !! plunge (mm/min) !! rpm !! cooling !! notes  
! cutter !! diameter (mm) !! speed (mm/min) !! plunge (mm/min) !! attack (mm) !! rpm !! cooling !! notes  
|-
|-
| single-flute || 2.0 || 300 || 30 || 0.5 || 10,000 || none || Great result, more should be doable!
| single-flute || 2.0 || 300 || 30 || 0.5 || 10,000 || none || Great result, more should be doable!
|-
|-
| single-flute || 2.0 || 400 || 30 || 0.75 || 10,000 || none || Looks good, might be the limit before it shows.
| single-flute || 2.0 || 400 || 30 || 0.75 || 10,000 || none || Looks good, might be the limit before it shows.
|-
| single-flute || 3.175 || 100 || 50 || 0.5 || 10,000 || none || Looks okay, but seems to be the limit. 300mm/min also tested, PMMA was melting.
|-
| <del>single-flute</del> || <del>3.175</del> || <del>80</del> || <del>50</del> || <del>1.0</del> || <del>10,000</del> || <del>none</del> || <del>Too much. Melting after a couple of minutes (Attack 2.00 Speed 100 failed miserably with melting)</del>
|-
|-
|}
|}
'''Cutter diameter of 2.00mm seems to be the most viable method - maybe trying a higher speed is an option?'''


= Engraving =
= Engraving =
Line 26: Line 31:
= Poplar plywood (Pappelsperrholz) =
= Poplar plywood (Pappelsperrholz) =
{| border="1" class="wikitable sortable"
{| border="1" class="wikitable sortable"
! cutter !! diameter (mm) !! speed (mm/min) !! attack (mm) !! plunge (mm/min) !! rpm !! cooling !! notes  
! cutter !! diameter (mm) !! plunge (mm/min) !! speed (mm/min) !! attack (mm) !! rpm !! cooling !! notes  
|-
| single-flute || 2.0 ||30 ||  300 || 2.0 || 10,000 || none || Great result, more should be doable!
|-
| single-flute || 2.0 || 80 || 500 || 2.0 || 10,000 || none || Great result, more should be doable!
|-
| single-flute || 3.175 || 80 || 500 || 3.0 || 10,000 || none || '''''Too much! Smells burnt!'''''
|-
|-
| single-flute || 2.0 || 300 || 30 || 2.0 || 10,000 || none || Great result, more should be doable!
| single-flute || 2.0 || 80 || 500 || 3.0 || 10,000 || none || Great result, maybe the limit with this setup?
|-
|-
|}
|}
Line 48: Line 59:
| single-flute || 3.175 || 555 || 1.00 || 127  || 10,000 || none || Works out fine, more speed or attack should be possible.
| single-flute || 3.175 || 555 || 1.00 || 127  || 10,000 || none || Works out fine, more speed or attack should be possible.
|-
|-
| single-flute || 3.175 || 555 || 2.00 || 127  || 10,000 || none || Works out fine, more speed or attack should be possible.
| single-flute || 3.175 || 600 || 2.00 || 127  || 10,000 || none || Works out fine, more speed or attack should be possible.
|-
| single-flute || 3.175 || 600 || 3.05 || 127  || 10,000 || none || I think that's the limit without more cooling or a different spindle. Maybe a little less might be better (2.5/500).
|-
| single-flute || 3.175 || 600 || 2.5 || 127  || 10,000 || none || This might be the best setting with 3.175mm cutter.
|-
| single-flute || 2.0 || 600 || TBD || 127  || 10,000 || none || TBD. If no pockets, and cutting depth is not too high, are needed, this might cut faster!
|-
|-
|}
|}
Line 61: Line 78:
* Left
* Left
** Cutting speed: 555mm/min
** Cutting speed: 555mm/min
** Attack: 2.00mm
** Attack (only outer cut, inner are done with 1.00mm): 2.00mm


= Footer =
= Footer =

Latest revision as of 20:51, 9 May 2024

🚧 This is very much likely to change - I'm still learning every day!

I used a 500W china spindle for my tests.

Plexiglas (PMMA)

Melts at 160°C (even earlier than your printer's PLA or PETG).

These are the main challenges:

  • Make sure the chips leave the flute so they can't friction weld (dust shoe, compressed air)
  • Finding the highest cutting volume (diameter*speed*attack) while keeping the tool as cool as possible
cutter diameter (mm) speed (mm/min) plunge (mm/min) attack (mm) rpm cooling notes
single-flute 2.0 300 30 0.5 10,000 none Great result, more should be doable!
single-flute 2.0 400 30 0.75 10,000 none Looks good, might be the limit before it shows.
single-flute 3.175 100 50 0.5 10,000 none Looks okay, but seems to be the limit. 300mm/min also tested, PMMA was melting.
single-flute 3.175 80 50 1.0 10,000 none Too much. Melting after a couple of minutes (Attack 2.00 Speed 100 failed miserably with melting)

Cutter diameter of 2.00mm seems to be the most viable method - maybe trying a higher speed is an option?

Engraving

0.5mm deep TBD TBD

Poplar plywood (Pappelsperrholz)

cutter diameter (mm) plunge (mm/min) speed (mm/min) attack (mm) rpm cooling notes
single-flute 2.0 30 300 2.0 10,000 none Great result, more should be doable!
single-flute 2.0 80 500 2.0 10,000 none Great result, more should be doable!
single-flute 3.175 80 500 3.0 10,000 none Too much! Smells burnt!
single-flute 2.0 80 500 3.0 10,000 none Great result, maybe the limit with this setup?

Pine plywood (Kiefersperrholz)

cutter diameter (mm) speed (mm/min) attack (mm) plunge (mm/min) rpm cooling notes
single-flute 2.0 400 2.0 100 10,000 none Works out fine, more speed should be possible.

OSB (Grobspanplatten)

cutter diameter (mm) speed (mm/min) attack (mm) plunge (mm/min) rpm cooling notes
single-flute 3.175 500 0.75 80 10,000 none Works out fine, more speed should be possible.
single-flute 3.175 555 1.00 127 10,000 none Works out fine, more speed or attack should be possible.
single-flute 3.175 600 2.00 127 10,000 none Works out fine, more speed or attack should be possible.
single-flute 3.175 600 3.05 127 10,000 none I think that's the limit without more cooling or a different spindle. Maybe a little less might be better (2.5/500).
single-flute 3.175 600 2.5 127 10,000 none This might be the best setting with 3.175mm cutter.
single-flute 2.0 600 TBD 127 10,000 none TBD. If no pockets, and cutting depth is not too high, are needed, this might cut faster!

Examples

12mm OSB, 3.175 single flute

GCode created with LaserWeb4.

  • Left
    • Cutting speed: 555mm/min
    • Attack: 1.00mm
  • Left
    • Cutting speed: 555mm/min
    • Attack (only outer cut, inner are done with 1.00mm): 2.00mm

Footer

  • Links
    • TBD